Skip to main content

Supreme Court Ruling—Tortious Interference


In a Supreme Court case where oral arguments were held in Longview, the Court recently issued an opinion on the tortious interference with inheritance cause of action. Due to a split among the Courts of Appeals regarding whether Texas recognizes this cause of action, the case has received quite a bit of attention. The Supreme Court declined to adopt the cause of action under the facts of the case, but did not rule out doing so later. Since there was an adequate remedy through the imposition of a constructive trust, the Court did not have to rule on the tortious interference issue.

Case Facts: Lesey Kinsel sold her family ranch when she was in her mid-90s, shortly before her death. Lesey had been persuaded that she needed to liquidate the ranch to cover the cost of her medical care, when in fact she held around $1.4 million in marketable securities. The jury awarded $3.056 million, the amount of Lesey’s proceeds from the sale, and the court imposed a constructive trust awarding that amount to the family members who would have inherited the funds had the ranch not been sold.

Constructive Trust: The Supreme Court made a strong statement in support of the constructive trust remedy: “the specific instances in which equity impresses a constructive trust are numberless, as numberless as the modes by which property may be obtained through bad faith and unconscientious acts.”

Result: Whether Texas will adopt the tortious interference cause of action will be determined by a future case. In this case the Supreme Court ruled against the wrongdoer, affirmed the damage award, and sent a message that the constructive trust is a broad and effective remedy to correct wrongs in inheritance dispute situations.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Probate Dispute News: Aretha Franklin’s Holographic Will, by Steve Spitzer

Aretha Franklin’s legendary singing career spanned five-plus decades. The “Queen of Soul” made the most appearances on the Billboard charts of any female performer ever. She died from pancreatic cancer in August of 2018 at age 76.   1. Probate Case   It was initially thought that Franklin died without a will. A niece, Sabrina Owens, was appointed as the administrator of the estate, which is pending in a Detroit suburb. Earlier this month, Owens was searching Franklin’s home and discovered three handwritten wills.   Two wills from 2010 were found inside a locked cabinet. One from 2014 was found in a spiral bound notebook under the cushions of a couch. The wills are difficult to read, are disorganized and look like rough drafts. Words are crossed out and are written in the margins. The primary beneficiaries are Franklin’s four sons.   2. Disputed Issues   The four sons have been unable to reach an agreement about the validity of the wills. Owens has filed a pe

New Texas Power of Attorney Act

Texas recently adopted much of the Uniform Power of Attorney Act, resulting in a significant overhaul of the prior Texas power of attorney statutes. A few of the more significant changes are: Standing to Sue for POA Abuse: As discussed in the October 2016 edition of this newsletter, standing to sue a fiduciary for misuse of a power of attorney was previously limited. The new act considerably broadens the persons who have standing to sue. Increasing POA Acceptance: POAs are often ineffective due to the reluctance of third parties to accept and rely on them. The new act requires third parties to provide a specific, written reason for the refusal to accept the POA, and creates a limited right to seek court intervention to force the acceptance of a POA. Estate Planning Powers: If desired by the principal creating the POA, “hot powers” can be included that allow the agent holding the POA to engage in estate planning activity for the principal such as creating trusts, making

Things to Know Before Hiring an Attorney

With so many attorneys out there, selecting the right one can feel overwhelming. If you select the wrong lawyer for your case the results can be utterly detrimental. So it’s important to do your homework before finally settling on an attorney.   Here are some important questions to ask before agreeing to hire any lawyer: Does the lawyer have experience in the type of law your case is in? Almost every lawyer has his or her area(s) of specialty. An attorney with decades of business litigation experience is the wrong person to hire for your DUI case. You will want to make sure you find a lawyer who understands your case, your needs as a client and has expertise in the legal matter you’re dealing with. Who is the lawyer’s typical client? This is something important to consider. Let’s say you are an individual with a particular legal problem, but the attorney you're meeting with represents only corporations, this will not be the attorney best suited for you and your